The man who fired 11 shots from his girlfriend’s truck into a vehicle after a 2025 confrontation, killing the driver and critically wounding her daughter, was found guilty Thursday of Second-Degree Murder and seven related charges, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Jubal John Simmons, 24, was found guilty of Second-Degree Murder with a Firearm, 3 counts of Attempted Second-Degree Murder with a Firearm, 2 counts of Shooting into an Occupied Vehicle, and 1 count of Discharging a Firearm from a Vehicle.

Co-defendant Ivybella Encino, who was driving the truck as it passed the victims and while Simmons fired 11 rounds, was found guilty of Accessory after the Fact to Attempted Second-Degree Murder, Accessory after the Fact to Shooting into an Occupied Vehicle, and Fleeing and Attempting to Elude (high speed/reckless).

The jury took less than 90 minutes to deliberate following Prosecutor Frank Sullivan’s closing argument. The defendants, each with a separate attorney, were tried together. Circuit Court Judge Timothy Register set sentencing for Feb. 20.

 

The two were charged in the Feb. 22, 2025 road rage shooting at U.S. 231 and Harrison Avenue that killed Georgeann Garner and critically injured her 19-year-old daughter. Two other passengers in the vehicle were not injured by any of the 11 shots.

The shooting took place after an altercation between a passenger in the car and Encino, but that had ended and everyone was back in their vehicles when Simmons opened fire.

“What happened at that intersection was an absolute tragedy,” Sullivan, who was assisted by Prosecutor Laurie Hughes, told jurors during his closing argument. “Most importantly, every single witness that you heard agreed that they thought the altercation was over.”

Sullivan told jurors the brief altercation – Encino believed the victim cut her off in heavy traffic –  should not play a part in deciding the verdict because it was over as the defendants sat behind the victims at the traffic light just before the shooting.

“There was no threat of violence when Ivybella pulled around Ms. Garner’s vehicle and (Simmons) fired not 1, but 11 shots,” Sullivan said.

RELATED: Man guilty of molesting child in Holmes

RELATED: Habitual Offender drug trafficker gets 45 years

The evidence showed that the defendants continued north on U.S. 231. Nearby Panama City police officers gave chase, with Encino turning left onto 19^th Street, then right behind a group of buildings and the water tower before circling the Holiday Inn. Surveillance video tracks the pursuit and shows Simmons throwing the pistol into large drainage ditch. Encino continued her flight, driving across a grassy area, and through a large ditch before colliding with a patrol car, disabling both vehicles.

Encino was taken into custody there. Simmons fled on foot but was captured a short distance away. The gun was recovered by police.

Basford thanked Panama City police for their fast reaction and capture of the defendants. He also thanked the Florida Department of Law Enforcement for its forensics work tying the gun to the shootings.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

BONIFAY – A Bonifay man was found guilty on Tuesday of Lewd or Lascivious Molestation of a Child Under the Age of 12, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

A Holmes County jury needed only 17 minutes to return a guilty verdict against Michael Nathaniel Simmons, 44, of Bonifay. Holmes County Chief Prosecutor Jacob Cook called 8 witnesses – including the victim, another child who was molested by the defendant, and a woman who testified the defendant molested her in 2014 when she was a child.

In Tuesday’s case, the facts presented at trial showed the defendant molested a young girl in 2024 at her church. The child reported it to her mother, who contacted law enforcement.

“I’m so thankful the jury held Nathan Simmons accountable for his predatory behavior,” Cook said. “He has a track record of preying on children, and hopefully with this verdict he will never have the chance to touch another child.”

RELATED: Repeated drug traffickers gets 45 years

RELATED: Holmes murder defendant sentenced

Basford thanked the Holmes County Sheriff’s Office for its work, and the Gulf Coast Children’s Advocacy Center for its forensic interview of the victim. Basford also thanked the victims for their courage in coming forward and testifying. Circuit Court Judge Russell Roberts ordered Simmons held without bond until his Feb. 18^th sentencing. He faces up to life in prison.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

 

A man found guilty of trafficking both in fentanyl and methamphetamine last month has been sentenced to 45 years in prison, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Joshua A. Smith, 41, was found guilty Dec. 3 of Trafficking in Fentanyl (between 14 and 28 grams), Trafficking in Methamphetamine, and Unlawful Use of a Two-Way Communication Device.

Prosecutor Frank Sullivan successfully sought to have him sentenced under Florida’s Habitual Felony Offender enhanced penalties. Circuit Court Judge Brantley Clark sentenced the defendant to 30 years in prison on the fentanyl charge, to be followed by 15 years for the methamphetamine charge.

The defendant has previously been to prison five times, with his most recent incarceration for drug trafficking. He was released from prison less than a year prior to being arrested in this case.

RELATED: Holmes man gets 45 years for murder

RELATED: Georgia man guilty of severely beating woman

At trial, Sullivan showed that on April 7, 2024, Panama City police made a probable cause stop of the defendant.

During a search of the defendant’s truck, police found “black magnetic box” stuck to the bottom of the vehicle. It contained about 67 grams of pressed fentanyl pills, 15 grams of methamphetamine, marijuana, and cash.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

(This release was updated to update the nature of the charges)

CHIPLEY – A woman working as a correctional officer at the Northwest Florida Reception Center was found guilty Thursday of 10 counts related to accepting money for Official Behavior and using a two-way device to do so , State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Tina Marie Wallace, 50, was found guilty of 5 counts of Unlawful Compensation for Official Behavior, and 5 counts of Unlawful Use of Two-Way Communications Device. The first 5 charges are Second Degree Felonies punishable by up to 15 years in prison; the other 5 charges are Third Degree Felonies punishable by up to 5 years in prison.

The jury deliberated for about 2 hours after Washington County Chief Prosecutor Megan Ford presented the case. Chief Circuit Court Judge Christopher Patterson set sentencing for March 3.

RELATED: Follow us on Facebook for up-do-date-releases
RELATED: Holmes killer sentenced to 45 years

An investigation by the Department of Corrections Officer of Inspector General determined that in September and October of 2022 alone, Wallace received more than $24,000 from inmates, relatives of inmates, or associates of inmates via her CashApp accounts.

“This case was about accountability,” Ford said. “The evidence showed a clear pattern of improper payments, and today’s verdict affirms that public trust cannot be bought.”

Ford called three witnesses to prove her case: DOC Office of Inspector General Inspector Steven Lee, a co-defendant and former correctional officer who worked with Wallace, and a family member of an inmate who thought she was sending money for food.

As Detective Lee began examining the CashApp records he was able to make connections to inmates, inmates’ family members, and inmates’ visitors by cross-referencing CashApp information with DOC records. Eighty-seven transactions occurred from Sept. 1, 2022-Oct. 20, 2022 and well over half of those sending money to Tina Wallace’s CashApp had connections to the Department of Corrections.

Many of the transactions indicated on the subject line it was for the benefit of a certain inmate. Additionally, the State presented evidence that Tina Wallace sent money to known inmates, regularly communicated with inmates on the phone off hours, and was in control of housing and disciplinary reports all during a time when violence and contraband drops were at an all-time high at the facility.

During this period, Tina Wallace transferred the money from the CASHAPP Account to her personal bank account 21 times. The amount transferred over a month-and-a-half was well over half of her yearly salary.

Basford thanked the DOC Office of Inspector General for its thorough investigation that helped lead to guilty verdicts on all counts.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

BONIFAY – As potential jurors gathered here for jury selection Tuesday, Anthony Lee Hicks Jr. decided to plead guilty to Second-Degree Murder and was sentenced to 45 years in prison, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Hicks Jr., 32, pled guilty to shooting and killing Marcus Kale Fournier, 25, on March 26, 2024. Circuit Court Judge Russell Roberts accepted the plea and the sentence. Under Florida’s 10-20-Life Statute, Hicks Jr. must serve the first 25 years day-for-day.

Prosecutor Peter Overstreet was prepared to present evidence and witnesses proving that Hicks, with his father as a passenger, wrecked his VW Jetta near County 173 and Parrish Road. Overstreet said it appeared the victim stopped to help Hicks Jr. and his father, and for unknown reasons Hicks Jr. shot him multiple times, killing him.

“This is a senseless tragedy where Mr. Fournier was simply being a good citizen and helping people he thought were severely injured,” Overstreet said. “While we may never know exactly why the defendant shot and killed Mr. Fournier, one thing is clear: the defendant’s intoxication played a huge role. With this plea the victim’s family can now start to have some closure.”

The evidence showed that around 4 a.m., the Florida Highway Patrol responded to the crash in Holmes County. A white VW Jetta had flipped over and hit a tree.

When troopers arrived they initially found the victim, Marcus Kale Fournier, deceased behind another white car on the side of the road. Initially FHP thought Fournier had been ejected from the vehicle until they and EMS noticed a gunshot wound to Fournier’s head.

The Holmes County Sheriff’s Office responded and determined the defendant had been driving at a high rate of speed while under the influence of methamphetamine, cannabis, and alcohol. The Defendant’s father had fallen asleep in the passenger seat and was awakened to his son, the defendant, removing him from the flipped wreckage.

The 911 call placed by the defendant on the victim’s cell phone revealed a highly agitated and intoxicated defendant who was heard arguing with his father. During the call the defendant’s father can be heard saying “what did you do?!” “You shot him!” Law enforcement found a .40 caliber Taurus firearm and three spent shell casings.

RELATED: Georgia man guilty of severely beating woman

RELATED: Former teacher guilty of having sex with student

Fournier had simply stopped on his way to work, as a Good Samaritan, to render aid to the occupants of the vehicle. Analysis on the firearm recovered at the scene revealed the Defendant’s DNA. An autopsy of the victim revealed a gunshot wound to the chin which exited his skull, and two gunshot wounds to the back.

Basford thanked the Holmes County Sheriff’s Office, Florida Highway Patrol, and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement for their work and collaboration on the case.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

A Georgia man who badly beat his girlfriend and threatened her with a gun during a 2024 trip to Bay County was found guilty of multiple felonies by a 6-person jury Friday, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Jurors deliberated about an hour before finding Anthony Wayn Worley, 62, of Moreland, Ga., guilty of Aggravated Battery, Domestic Battery by Strangulation, and False Imprisonment. He also was guilty of Assault, a misdemeanor. Circuit Court Judge Brantley Clark set sentencing for Feb. 18.

Prosecutor Jackson White, assisted by Prosecutor Christopher Walters, presented evidence and witnesses proving the defendant badly beat the defendant in their Thomas Drive hotel room Oct. 12, 2024. The victim testified Worley also tried to smother her with a pillow and threatened her with a gun.

The victim, who was crying and screaming loudly for help, managed to get out of the room but was being dragged back in when a Good Samaritan heard her cries for help and intervened, getting the victim to safety and awaiting the arrival of Bay County Sheriff’s Office deputies.

“But for the brave actions of the Good Samaritan responding to her screams for help, there is no way to know what would have happened if the defendant had gotten her back into that room,” White said after the trial. “Because of his help, we do know the man who beat and threatened to shoot the victim is now facing prison time.”

The victim testified she and the defendant had been dating in Georgia and were in Bay County scouting for a possible place to live. She said both had been drinking and were outside when someone, unsolicited, complimented her on her appearance. That upset the defendant, who began arguing with her, she said.

She testified she headed back to the room, telling the defendant she was “going back to Georgia. He didn’t like that.”

Inside the room, she said, the defendant repeatedly punched her, tried to smother her with a pillow, and waved a loaded gun at her saying, “I got one bullet for you and one bullet for me.”

She managed to escape the room, but the defendant caught her.

RELATED: Former band teacher facing Life for sex with student

RELATED: Repeat sex offender sentenced to Life

The testimony of the victim and the Good Samaritan was solidified by video surveillance at the hotel, with audio, that captured the victim’s repeated cries and screams for help.

The video shows the defendant, arms wrapped around the victim from behind, shoving her toward their room as she screams, struggles and yells for help. The Good Samaritan comes from around corner and attempts to help the woman, but she and the defendant fell into the room.

Eight seconds later the victim is seen rising in the doorway and escaping again, still yelling for help, with the two men still inside the room. Eight more seconds pass before the Good Samaritan appears outside the door and tells the victim to go to his room for safety as he stops the defendant from following her.

He then awaited the arrival of deputies.

The victim suffered a broken nose and orbital socket that required emergency medical treatment, as well as a number of braces and scrapes.

Basford thanked the Bay County Sheriff’s Office and the Good Samaritan who got the victim to safety and testified Friday.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Former middle school band teacher Lindsey Stuart is facing up to three Life sentences after being found guilty Thursday of engaging in a 10-month relationship that became sexual with a 14-year-old student, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Stuart, 40, was found guilty as charged of 3 counts of Sexual Battery upon a Child 12 Years of Age or Older, but Under 18 Years of Age, by a Person in Custodial Authority. Each charge is punishable by up to Life in prison. Circuit Court Judge Brantley Clark set sentencing for Feb. 16.

Prosecutor Frank Sullivan presented evidence and called 4 witnesses – the victim, her sister, and both her parents – to prove that Stuart was 38 years old when he engaged in a sexual relationship with the 14-year-old student in 2023. The victim testified the two had sexual relations dozens of times, most often at the school. Jurors took just over 30 minutes to reach their verdicts.

“The defendant’s actions in this case are inexcusable,” Sullivan said after the verdict. “Parents entrust their most prized possessions, their children, to teachers and others in authority. This defendant abused his authority and violated the trust that parents must have when their children are with others.”

RELATED: Repeat sex offender sentenced to Life

RELATED: Guilty verdicts in sexual battery of 9-year-old

The evidence included 29 pages of handwritten letters from the defendant to the victim – found by the victim’s mother when she became suspicious of Stuart – in which he professed his “love” for the student. He also referenced sexual acts with the student, spending the night with her, and how the night he picked her up after she snuck out of her sister’s window was the start “of a very ‘active’ few months. We couldn’t keep our hands off each other,” he wrote.

Stuart testified any references to sex or illegal acts found in those letters were a product of his “fantasy, inappropriate fantasy,” and not real.

On cross-examination, Sullivan asked Stuart how he defined “fantasy”?

“It means something that’s not real that you hope might happen someday,” the defendant said.

Sullivan pointed out that the defendant wrote lines like, “It was a great night,” “It will be a great night”, and “Through all of the physical/sexual things we were still growing so much as a couple in other ways too,” rather than saying they “will still be growing.”

“That’s not a fantasy of future actions that you hoped might happen, that’s about something that’s already been done,” Sullivan said. “These letters … are a timeline of the development of your relationship with the victim.”

Other evidence included a note the defendant wrote to the victim’s father. Stuart was caught Facetiming with the victim before the family knew there had been physical contact with their daughter. Her father wrote to Stuart warning him his behavior was inappropriate, and to never contact her again.

In response, Stuart wrote the father, “This next sentence is going to be hard for you to read, but it’s true. I love your daughter … and I want to cherish her, respect her, protect her.”

The defendant then asked if the victim’s parents would “sit down somewhere and talk” with him about his feelings.

Basford thanked the Bay County Sheriff’s Office and Gulf Coast Children’s Advocacy Center for their work in investigating the case and gathering the evidence that helped lead to a conviction.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

 

A 56-year-old Sexual Predator was sentenced to Life in prison without the possibility of parole Wednesday after a jury found him guilty of molesting a 6-year-old girl, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Michael Neaves Butts, of Alabama, was found guilty of Lewd or Lascivious Molestation on a person under the age of 12 after a one-day trial. Circuit Court Judge Brantley Clark then ordered the Life sentence.

In 1997 the defendant was found guilty of Attempted Sexual Battery of a young girl and ultimately was sentenced to a total of about 16 years in prison. He also was designated as a Sexual Predator. He was living in Alabama at the time of the most recent offense, which occurred while he was visiting here.

“The pain and suffering unleashed by this defendant on 2 innocent children more than 20 years apart is hard to articulate,” Prosecutor J.P. Ferreira said after the verdict. “Because this victim came forward, he will spend the rest of his life in a prison cell where he belongs.”

FOLLOW: SAO on Facebook for latest news

RELATED: Guilty verdict in child sex abuse case 

Prosecutor J.P. Ferreira presented evidence and testimony that included both the 6-year-old victim in the recent case, and the sexual abuse victim who was 8 years old when Butts was convicted of sexually abusing her in 1997.

In Wednesday’s case, the sexual abuse came to light during an ongoing Department of Children and Families investigation into the living conditions at the child’s home in 2023. The defendant was in Bay County during a portion of that time, and when he left the victim reported the abuse.

Gulf Coast Children’s Advocacy Center personnel trained in working with child sex victims interviewed the child, who detailed the abuse.

Basford thanked the Springfield Police Department, DCF, and the GCCAC for their active role in the case.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

A jury returned guilty verdicts Tuesday against a man who was in his mid-teens when he sexually battered a 9-year-old girl on two different occasions.

Garrett William Bowden, who lived out of state at the time of the 2017 offenses, is now 23. He was found guilty of two counts of Sexual Battery Upon a Person Less than 12 Years of Age. Circuit Court Judge Brantley Clark set sentencing for Feb. 16. The charges are punishable by up to Life in prison.

Prosecutor Frank Sullivan called witnesses – including the victim – and presented evidence proving the defendant sexually battered the victim during the summer of 2017. The defendant was 15 at the time, the victim was 9.

“This victim showed amazing strength in coming forward and testifying,” Sullivan said after the trial. “She was 9 years old when she was raped, she’s had to live with that pain for the last 9 years, and today she had to relive it on the stand.

“We are glad she saw justice carried out and that the defendant will be held accountable for what he did to her.”

The victim, now 18, testified Tuesday that the defendant warned her not to tell anyone. And for nearly 7 years she did not, she said, out of fear.

But testimony showed that in 2023 the victim, a teen at that point, overheard a conversation that the defendant was moving back to Panama City and immediately disclosed what had happened back in 2017. Lynn Haven Police Department officers were notified and the Bay County Sheriff’s Office joined when it was learned one sexual battery occurred in unincorporated Bay County. Gulf Coast Children’s Advocacy Center personnel trained in working with child sex victims interviewed the child.

The defendant was arrested in Tallahassee in 2024.

Basford thanked the LHPD, BCSO, GCCAC and other agencies that collaborated to put together a case that yielded positive results years after the offenses took place.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

An Alabama man who unsuccessfully claimed he was expecting to meet a woman he found on a social media app was sentenced to 25 years in prison Thursday, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Marques Isaiah Player, of Sylacuaga, Ala., was found guilty of Aggravated Battery with a Firearm (great bodily injury) after Prosecutor Frank Sullivan presented the case during a 1-day trial Nov. 5. Circuit Court Judge Brantley Clark handed down the sentence Thursday.

“This case presents a cautionary tale about meeting and ‘hooking up’ with random strangers you meet on dating apps,” Sullivan said following the trial. “Not everyone on the internet is who they claim to be, and that can be dangerous for both parties. Mr. Player has 25 years to think about that.”

Part of Player’s defense was that he thought he was messaging with a woman on social media apps in the hours before the May 1, 2022, shooting. But the evidence made it clear he knew the victim was a man.

They agreed to meet at the defendant’s beach motel room. The defendant claimed it was only when he got in the truck that he realized it was a man, and he fired a shot out of fear when he saw an empty gun holster in the truck. The Bay County Sheriff’s Office investigation, however, showed through texts and messages that the defendant knew he was a meeting a man before the victim arrived. And jurors agreed.

RELATED: FL Supreme Court upholds death penalty in Hunt case

RELATED: Bonifay ATM robbery leads to 15-year prison sentence

Surveillance video showed that the victim pulled into the hotel parking lot and sat there for several minutes. The defendant is seen leaving his hotel room, pulling a gun from his pants pocket, racking a round into the chamber and then putting the gun back in his pocket before eventually walking over to the victim’s vehicle.

The defendant is seen opening the passenger door of the victim’s truck but only remaining for seconds before shooting the victim and running away on foot. The victim was able to call 911 for assistance while the defendant and a friend fled in the friend’s Jeep. The Sheriff’s Office’s BAYROC monitoring system was used to show it crossed the Hathaway Bridge headed into Panama City minutes after the shooting. At 4:02 a.m. the vehicle, and the suspects, were found and taken into custody at a gas station near 23rd Street and U.S. 231. The gun used in the shooting was in the vehicle.

Basford thanked the Sheriff’s Office for its work on the case and the quick arrest.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.