Judge Upholds Life Sentence for Falcon in 1997 Murder

Posted on October 27, 2026 by Admin SA

For the second time in six years, Rebecca Lee Falcon’s request for a sentence modification in the murder of cab driver Richard Phillips in 1997 has been denied, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Circuit Court Judge Brantley Clark Tuesday rejected Falcon’s request from her February sentencing review writing, “Based on review of the entirety of the record in the present case, this Court believes the sentence of Life imprisonment imposed at Defendant’s July 2020 resentencing remains the most appropriate sentence.”

“We hope that this order allows Mr. Phillips’ family to finally get the closure they deserve,” said Prosecutor Peter Overstreet.

Falcon was 15 when she shot Phillips in the back of the head on Nov. 19, 1997. The evidence showed she obtained a pistol from a co-defendant, test-fired it multiple times, and said she wanted to shoot someone in the back of the head.

Falcon and her co-defendant flagged down a cab driven by Phillips, with Falcon sitting in back. A short time later she shot the victim in the back of the head and fled. After the shooting she at first denied it, then laughed about it.

She was found guilty of First-Degree Murder in 1999 and sentenced to life in prison. Years later, the U.S. Supreme Court held that juveniles who are sentenced to life are entitled to present mitigating factors. At that 2020 resentencing Falcon again received life.

The law also entitles juveniles sentenced to life to seek a sentence review hearing after they have served 25 years, and that hearing for Falcon was held in February. Clark released his ruling Tuesday.

In such hearings the Court weighs, among other things, whether the offender demonstrates maturity and rehabilitation, remains at the same level of risk as at the original sentencing, and whether the defendant has shown sustained and sincere remorse.

Prosecutor Peter Overstreet during the February hearing.

Rebecca Falcon is escorted out of court after her February hearing.

At the two-day hearing, Overstreet cross-examined witnesses and argued that Falcon, now 44, did not meet the requirements set by law for a reduced sentence.

Overstreet argued, essentially, that the level of any remorse, maturity, education achievements, taking responsibility for her actions, or good behavior by Falcon was equal to the level she thought she had to “show” to get out of prison and was not genuine.

“Over the years she has sought to excuse her behavior, blaming the cab driver and others for her plight,” Overstreet said, noting that her participation in certain courses or actions often reflected whatever change had occurred in the law or in court, not at her own behest.

“While the Defendant has apologized to the victim’s family for killing him, she has not fully acknowledged why or how she committed this horrific murder,” Overstreet said. “Since her arrest nearly 30 years ago, the defendant has given various reasons and renditions on why and how she shot Mr. Phillips.

“The central question to be answered is: How do you rehabilitate a person who chooses to kill another?”

Judge Clark made similar findings in his order, writing that Falcon “continues to minimize her actions and refuses every opportunity ‘to state exactly what she had done.’ ”

“This Court cannot find that Defendant has shown sincere and sustained remorse for shooting and killing the victim,” he wrote. “Defendant initially denied her role in the crime. The day after the shooting, Defendant did not express any remorse and laughed about the murder. Instead, the record makes it clear that Defendant has refused to state exactly what she did and accept full responsibility for her action.”

He acknowledged Falcon is more mature now, as people naturally mature. But participating in programs does not equate to rehabilitation, he wrote.

Clark also noted the bulk of Falcon’s participation in programs occurred prior to specific hearing and resentencing dates and then tapered off.

“At best, Defendant has demonstrated that she understood her only opportunity for release required her to behave as a model inmate and to participate in programs while pursuing legal challenges to her life sentence and engaged in the behavior that would grant her favor with the Court,” Clark wrote. “As a result, the Court determines Defendant has not demonstrated rehabilitation.”

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Porter Sentenced to 30 Years for Shooting, Killing Friend During Argument

Posted on October 6, 2026October 6, 2026 by Admin SA

CHIPLEY – Kyle Michael Porter was sentenced to 30 years in prison Tuesday for killing a friend with a shot to the head as they argued following an unsuccessful fishing trip in 2024.

Chief Circuit Court Judge Christopher Patterson presided over the Sept. 23 trial that found the defendant guilty of Manslaughter with a Firearm and ordered the sentence. Chief Washington County Prosecutor Megan presented the case that led to the verdict after 35 minutes of deliberation.

Testimony and evidence at trial proved the defendant, victim Randy Joseph Lynn, and a third man went fishing at Joiner Lake off Teardrop Trail on April 27, 2024. The three men worked together.

There was arguing between the defendant and the victim during the trip, but when they returned to the dock, the victim was too intoxicated to get out of the boat on his own.

The victim was helped out of the boat and resumed his argument with the defendant.

A witness said the victim was unarmed during the argument when the defendant pulled his pistol and fired one shot into his head. The victim, whose blood-alcohol level was .257 – more than three times the legal driving limit – fell backward into the water and died.

The defendant claimed self-defense, but the witness, along with the victim’s level of intoxication proved he was unarmed and not a threat.

“This case is about 15 seconds on a dock and a decision that cannot be taken back,” Ford said at trial. “Randy Lynn did not have a weapon, he did not reach for Kyle’s gun, he did not touch him. Then Kyle introduced a loaded gun into the argument, and approximately 15 seconds passed before Kyle pulled the trigger.”

Basford thanked the Washington County Sheriff’s Office for its thorough investigation that helped lead to a successful outcome.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Man Guilty of Shooting Friend in Head During Alcohol-Fueled Argument

Posted on September 25, 2026 by Admin SA

CHIPLEY – A 6-person jury took 35 minutes Wednesday to find Kyle Michael Porter guilty as charged of Manslaughter with a Firearm for shooting a friend in the head as they argued following an unsuccessful fishing trip in 2024.

Chief Circuit Court Judge Christopher Patterson set Porter’s sentencing date for Oct. 6. He faces up to 30 years in prison.

Chief Washington County Prosecutor Megan Ford called six witnesses, including a third person on the fishing trip who witnessed the shooting on the defendant’s dock at Joiner Lake off Teardrop Trail. The witnesses and evidence proved the defendant pulled his gun during an argument on his dock after the trip and shot an unarmed Randy Joseph Lynn once in the head. Lynn fell backward into the lake and died quickly. All three men had been drinking.

“This case is about 15 seconds on a dock and a decision that cannot be taken back,” Ford told jurors. “Randy Lynn did not have a weapon, he did not reach for Kyle’s gun, he did not touch him. Then Kyle introduced a loaded gun into the argument … and approximately 15 seconds passed before Kyle pulled the trigger.

“The evidence will show this was a verbal confrontation with a heavily intoxicated 63-year-old man who moments before could not stand” to get out of the boat.

The victim’s blood-alcohol level was .257, more than three times the legal driving limit.

The evidence and testimony showed that Porter, the victim, and the third person on the fishing trip all worked together and planned a fishing trip on the lake for April 27, 2024. Porter and the third man drove to Southport that morning to pick up the victim, stopping for bait and beer on the way back.

The three were in a small dingy type boat.

The surviving witness said Porter was in back controlling the motor, the victim was in the center of the boat and he was in the front. All three were drinking beer and bourbon but they were not catching any fish.

As they headed back toward the defendant’s dock, they ran through a group of lily pads and the engine became clogged and quit working. In later statements to Washington County Sheriff’s Office investigators, Porter and the surviving witness said the victim became upset and started yelling and arguing with Porter about the engine problem.

The surviving witness said Porter was able to restart the motor and after a brief stop they headed back to the dock with the victim still upset and arguing most of the way. But by the time they reached the dock, the victim had reached a point of intoxication where he could not get out of the boat. The surviving witness tried to help pull him out and eventually he and Porter were able to pull the victim out.

“He started pushing (the third man) quite a bit,” Porter said in his statement. “He comes over to me because I told him to stop and he tells me that he will kill me and at that point man I felt threatened.” Porter claimed the victim charged him and he pulled the trigger.

RELATED: Armed Robber Gets 20 Years

But the other man said while the victim was intoxicated and argumentative, he never tried to get Porter’s gun, never charged Porter, and never tried to touch him or the gun. He said the victim had his hands in the air and was offering to fight both men when Porter pulled the trigger.

“Randy’s hands were up in the air like, ‘Bring it on,’ and Kyle says, ‘I’m going to shoot you’ and a couple of seconds later Kyle pulled the trigger,” the man testified. “Kyle could’ve just walked away.”

After the victim fell in the water, Porter called his wife who was inside their home up a hill from the dock and told her to call 911.

Basford thanked the Washington County Sheriff’s Office and for its thorough investigation that led to the arrest.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Armed Robber Sentenced to 20 years

Posted on September 23, 2026 by Admin SA

A man found guilty of hiding in a convenience store locker for an hour before confronting a clerk at gunpoint and robbing the store has been sentenced to 20 years in prison, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Nestor Omar Perez, 26, was found guilty of Robbery with a Firearm and Grand Theft (more than $750 but less than $5,000) on Sept. 2 He was arrested by the Panama City Police Department Oct. 13, 2023 robbery in the 3000 block of U.S. 98.

Prosecutor Morgan McAfee called 12 witnesses and presented evidence that it was Perez who walked into the store that day, confronted a clerk with a gun, and committed the robbery.

The evidence showed that the defendant, wearing a jacket partially concealing his face, confronted an employee inside the store and pointed a gun at him. The defendant grabbed money from the register and fled north on Beck Avenue.

Minutes later, with police saturating the area, police spotted the defendant walking in socks near 18^th Street and Wilmont Ave. When searched, the defendant had the gun used in the robbery which had distinctive tape wrapped around the handle. They also found cash in his pocket.

Nearby, police found a pair of distinctive green shoes and other clothing that matched what the robber was wearing in a trashcan. Officers also found several hundred dollars nearby on the ground. The amount found on the ground combined with the amount found in the defendant’s pocket matched the amount missing from the store’s register.

The defendant’s car was found parked a short distance away.

State Attorney Larry Basford thanked the Panama City Police Department for its fast response and thorough investigation that helped lead to a quick resolution.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

2 Life sentences + 145 years for Ranglin in 2024 Beach Murder

Posted on September 8, 2026September 8, 2026 by Admin SA

Andre Ranglin Tuesday was given two Life sentences plus 145 years in prison for 10 convictions stemming from the ambush murder of O’Neil Augustus McDonald in a Beach apartment parking lot in 2024.

Circuit Court Judge Shonna Young Gay imposed the jury’s recommendation of Life without parole for First Degree Murder, and also sentenced Ranglin to life for Attempted First Degree Premeditated Murder. Gay gave the defendant 20 years each for Attempted Burglary with Discharge of a Firearm, Attempted Felony Murder with a Firearm, and three counts of Attempted Second Degree Murder with a Firearm. Finally, she sentenced him to 15 years on each of his two convictions of being a Felon in Possession of a Firearm. A 12-person jury found Ranglin guilty as charged Aug. 31 after a six-day trial.

Lead Prosecutor Peter Overstreet, who along with Prosecutor Frank Sullivan presented the case, said that without the defendant’s lifelong incarceration, no one here would be safe.

Overstreet shows jurors the murder weapon

“We’d like to thank the jury for their time and attention to this case,” Overstreet said. “The verdict speaks for itself.

“Andre Ranglin will die in prison for the shooting, killing, and death of O’Neil Augustus McDonald,” he continued. “And it will be a lesson to all of those who come and want to commit crimes in our part of the world here that we will prosecute you and hold you to the highest and stiffest penalties that we can.”

The charges stemmed from an Aug. 6, 2024, shooting at a Beach apartment complex. The defendant hunted down victim O’Neil Augustus McDonald that night, walked up behind the group he was talking to, opened fire, chased the victim across the parking lot while shooting, and then put two shots into the victim’s head as he lay on the ground gravely wounded. McDonald was shot 11 times. Three shots were fired at a second victim who was struck once but survived.

During the trial, Overstreet and Sullivan called 28 witnesses and presented evidence showing the defendant and victim had worked together at a Beach restaurant. On Aug. 1, 2024, the two argued and Ranglin displayed a firearm. He was fired.

On Aug. 6 Ranglin returned and after another altercation with McDonald, Ranglin told the owner to close the business the next day because “bullets were gonna fly.”

About an hour later a Ring camera captured Ranglin walking through a foyer at the victim’s apartment complex headed toward the victim and the people he was talking to outside. A few seconds later a rapid series of shots and then screaming is heard on the Ring camera.

“He was just standing outside minding his own business, talking to friends, and they didn’t have a care in the world,” Overstreet told jurors. “But Andre Ranglin couldn’t let those last events go. When he started shooting that gun he did not care where any of those bullets went, he wanted revenge.”

Ranglin continued shooting as he chased McDonald across the parking lot. McDonald’s injuries included shots through the lungs, his pelvis, his shoulder, both hands, and his ankle before collapsing next to a retention pond.

A witness said Ranglin walked up to the victim, who was laying helpless, and fired two final shots into the top of his skull.

“The defendant wanted his revenge and he got it,” Overstreet told jurors. “The victim’s lungs had been hit, were filling with blood and he collapsed, his ankle shattered and broken with multiple gunshot wounds. But Andre Ranglin was not done. He was not satisfied. As McDonald lay helpless on the ground Ranglin kept coming and put two in his head.”

The defendant then turned his attention to the witness, who was screaming at him. She fled toward her apartment with Ranglin in pursuit and shooting at her – hitting her once – before she got inside her apartment.

He tried to force his way in as she fought to shut and lock the door. He fired a final shot through the door before fleeing.

The defendant was captured later the next day at a Dothan, Ala., motel.

State Attorney Larry Basford thanked the Panama City Beach Police Department for its handling of a chaotic crime scene and an investigation involving multiple agencies that led to a quick arrest and successful prosecution.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Shoeless Defendant Guilty of Armed Robbery

Posted on September 4, 2026 by Admin SA

A jury took 10 minutes Wednesday to find a Panama City man guilty of the 2023 robbery of a U.S. 98 convenience store.

Nestor Omar Perez, 26, was found guilty as charged of Robbery with a Firearm and Grand Theft (more than $750 but less than $5,000). He was arrested by Panama City Police Department Deputy Chief Kristain Shaw minutes after the Oct. 13, 2023 robbery in the 3000 block of U.S. 98.

Prosecutor Morgan McAfee called 12 witnesses and presented evidence that it was Perez who walked into the store that day, confronted a clerk with a gun, and committed the robbery.

“The jury’s 10-minute decision showed the strength of the evidence in this case,” McAfee said. “Circumstantial cases can be difficult, but the evidence in this one was indisputable.”

Minutes later, with police saturating the area, Shaw spotted the defendant walking in socks near 18^th Street and Wilmont Ave. When searched, the defendant had the gun used in the robbery which had distinctive tape wrapped around the handle. They also found cash in his pocket.

Lt. Richard Thore was searching the area as well and noticed a home near 17^th Street and Chestnut Avenue that had a tall wooden fence blocking the view of the yard from the street. He decided to check the yard and saw a large city trash container by the house. He looked inside and found a pair of green shoes – and other clothing – that matched the ones the suspect was wearing on video when he fled the store.

Officers also found several hundred dollars nearby on the ground. The amount found on the ground combined with the amount found in the defendant’s pocket matched the amount missing from the store’s register.

The defendant’s car was found parked a short distance away.

Sentencing is set for Sept. 18.

State Attorney Larry Basford thanked the Panama City Police Department for its fast response and thorough investigation that helped lead to a quick resolution.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

85-year Sentence for Man Guilty of Chasing, Firing into Car

Posted on August 14, 2026 by Admin SA

A Panama City man convicted of opening fire on a vehicle with four occupants, striking one, was sentenced to a total of 85 years in prison Friday.

Martae Lemon Coleman, 29, was found guilty July 29 of four Counts of Attempted Second-Degree Murder – with one count involving serious bodily. Circuit Court Judge Timothy Register sentenced the defendant to 25 years on the first charge, and 20 years each of the other three. He also was found guilty of Shooting into an Occupied Vehicle.

State Attorney Larry Basford said that under Florida’s 10-20-Life law, those are minimum-mandatory sentences and they must be served consecutively and day-for-day over 85 years.

Prosecutors Jeff Moore and Morgan Morrell called 9 witnesses, including the victims, to prove that there was a verbal disturbance involving the defendant and a friend with the shooting victim and his friends in the parking lot of the Gold Nugget on U.S. 98 on Sept. 29, 2024. But it had ended and the victims had no idea the defendant was following their vehicle until he pulled beside them and opened fire at a Panama City Beach intersection 5 miles away.

The driver was struck in the hip before the defendant fled. He was found and arrested the next day.

The victim’s father said he was sound asleep that morning when his phone rang around 4 a.m.

“Imagine getting a phone call like that at 4 in the morning,” he said. “That’s my baby son. That was devastating. It’s going to affect him for the rest of his life. And it could’ve been worse and we might not have a son today.”

The victim’s mother said they made the drive here not knowing the exact details, which was it’s own kind of horror.

“No one knew,” she said. “All we knew was there was blood and he’d been shot.”

She also referenced the defense’s request that the court note the defendant’s military service. The victim’s mother said she is from a military family as well.

“We are held to a higher standard in everything we do,” she said. “You must think about your actions before you make dumb decisions. He chased my son for 5 miles and in 5 miles he didn’t think about what he was doing was wrong. We could’ve lost our son.”

Basford thanked the collaborative work that night between the Bay County Sheriff’s Office, Panama City Police Department and Panama City Beach Police Department in identifying the defendant through traffic cameras and getting him into custody.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Man Convicted of Firing 7 Shots at Spring Break Crowd Gets 36-Month Sentence

Posted on August 14, 2026August 14, 2026 by Admin SA

Prosecutor Jeffrey Moore, center, listens as Bay County Sheriff’s Office Maj. Jason Daffin, right, speaks at the sentencing for Zyion Robinson.

Panama City Beach Police Chief J.R. Talamantez speaks at sentencing Friday.

A 19-year-old Georgia man facing up to 15 years in prison for firing 7 shots at a Spring Break crowd last year was sentenced to 3 years in prison Friday.

A jury found Zyion Christopher Robinson guilty July 30 of Attempted Manslaughter with a Firearm, Discharging a Firearm in Public, and Improper Display of a Firearm. The first charge, because it involved the discharge of a firearm, is a Second-Degree Felony punishable by up to 15 years in prison. Prosecutor Jeffrey Moore asked for a 10-year sentence.

The testimony and evidence proved Robinson retrieved his gun after he came out on the losing end of a scuffle on April 11, 2025. He spotted members of the group and opened fire from a fast-food drive through toward a crowd of people. While no one was injured, it created chaos and panic on the Beach. Panama City Beach Police Chief J.R. Talamantez and Bay County Sheriff’s Office Maj. Jason Daffin both addressed the court seeking a stiff sentence both as punishment and as a deterrent to keep the beaches safer.

“The fact that our officers did not find blood on the ground when they arrived does not represent that our community did not bleed severely that night,” Talamantez said to the judge. “The fact that we did not find a body on the ground was luck. I can’t run a police department on luck.”

The defendant with a social media post showing off the firearm.

Talamantez, Daffin, and a witness from trial – she was at the drive-through with her young son in a car only feet away when Zyion fired – said the shooting left the community scared and in shock.

“People who come here for the beach should be able to go out on it … and I think our community deserves better,” Daffin said. “I ask that we send a message to anyone else who comes into our community and commits violence.”

A key witness at trial was at the drive-through with her 10-year-old son in the backseat when the defendant opened fire from feet away. She said in a victim impact statement that their lives are forever changed. She said her son slept in her bed for months out of fear, does not feel safe in traffic. They rarely eat out anymore and stay home during Spring Break.

“I am angry that my son has had to carry the consequences of someone else’s inability to manage his emotions,” she wrote. “I am angry that a gun was brought into a public place and used without regard for the lives of the people who happened to be there. I am angry that someone felt entitled to change the lives of strangers in such a profound and permanent way.”

She wrote that she hopes to one day return to a safe and peaceful feeling about her community.

“I am not asking the Court to see him only as the worst thing he has ever done,” she wrote. “But I am asking the Court to understand that what happened to us was real, that it mattered, and that the consequences did not end when the shooting stopped. There is a difference between having empathy for someone and excusing their actions.”

Moore, addressing the judge, said, “These are adult actions, it deserves an adult sentence.”

“What do you think he deserves?” Judge Register asked.

“Ten years,” Moore replied. “I think a 10-year-sentence is more than appropriate.”

Judge Register said that taking everything into consideration – from the defendant’s age and lack of criminal history to the impact on the community and people like the witness at the drive through – that a 36-month sentence was appropriate.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Teen guilty of firing 7 shots at Spring Break crowd

Posted on July 31, 2026 by Admin SA

A 19-year-old Georgia man who fired 7 shots at a crowd during Spring Break last year was found guilty of Attempted Manslaughter and two other charges Thursday, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

A jury deliberated 17 minutes before finding Zyion Christopher Robinson guilty of Attempted Manslaughter, with the special finding that he used a Firearm. That makes it a Second-Degree Felony punishable by up to 15 years in prison. Jurors also found the defendant guilty of Discharging a Firearm in Public and Improper Display of a Firearm. Circuit Court Judge set sentencing for August 14.

The defendant was arrested April 11, 2025, after he fired 7 shots from a Checkers drive-through toward a group of people he had a confrontation with minutes earlier in a different parking lot. No one was injured.

Prosecutors Jeffrey Moore and Andrew Eppling called 6 witnesses – including 2 co-defendants – and presented evidence in which the defendant admitted firing the gun – to prove that the defendant fired the shots toward a crowd that included a man who had “bested” him in an earlier confrontation.

A key witness was a local woman who was at the Checkers drive-through only yards away with her 10-year-old son in the car. A key piece of evidence was video that showed a green laser from the defendant’s weapon that was pointed toward the crowd, not into the air as the defendant claimed.

“It comes down to a laser, a momma, and an angry young man,” Moore told jurors. “She had her son in the car and tunnel vision locked in on that shooter. She knew where he was pointing that gun – downrange at the crowd at Zaxby’s.”

“Here’s why he would do that,” Moore continued. “He had been bested. He had agreed to a fight in the parking lot of Wal-Mart and he got bested there, pushed to the ground, his pride hurt, angry. He wasn’t going to be bested again with the gun he had.”

The evidence showed the defendant drove to Panama City Beach that weekend to meet and family and friends here for Spring Break. They went to the beach behind Pineapple Willie’s and a verbal argument broke out between them and another group before police moved in dispersed the entire crowd.

The defendant’s group went to their car, parked at Wal-Mart, and were re-engaged by the group they had argued with on the beach. It was decided a “no gun” fight would be held between the defendant and someone in the other group.

The fight started right there. Witnesses said the defendant was not faring well and went to the ground at one point before police again moved through the crowd dispersed.

The defendant walked to the nearby Checkers and soon noticed a crowd gathering in the Zaxby’s parking lot nearby. In that crowd were the people he had the earlier confrontation with. He said he wanted his gun from the car.

A surveillance video shows the defendant and a female co-defendant walking down the Checker’s drive-through and stopping beside the car belonging to the local witness with her child in the car.

“He’s a hurt angry young man and he needs his gun,” Eppling told jurors in his closing argument as he narrated the video. “And he’s going to make sure they don’t run across him again. He actually fires it 7 times, he’s angry and his adrenaline is flowing.”

And while the defendant later told police he fired into the air to scare away the nearby crowd, Eppling played the video in slow motion pointed out that the laser sight on the gun was hitting objects straight out, and the muzzle flashes went that way as well.

Later, when police approached the defendant, he said, “I’m your guy.” He admitted to the shooting but claimed he fired into the air. He initially claimed he threw the firearm into a lake, then said it was thrown into a sewer drain, then told police where he had hidden it. They recovered it from behind a retaining wall.

Basford thanked the Panama City Beach Police Department for its investigation in the middle of a chaotic Spring Break night.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Man Guilty of Opening Fire on Vehicle, Shooting 1 Occupant

Posted on July 29, 2026July 29, 2026 by Admin SA

A Panama City man who followed a car full of young adults for 5 miles after an argument in a parking lot and opened fire on their car was found guilty as charged Wednesday, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Martae Lemon Coleman, 29, was found guilty of 4 Counts of Attempted Second-Degree Murder and 1 count of Shooting into an Occupied Vehicle. Circuit Court Judge Timothy Register set sentencing for Aug. 14. The first four charges are First-Degree Felonies with up to Life sentences under Florida’s 10-20-Life law.

“The verbal altercation was over, there’s only one person in this whole crowd that it wasn’t over for and that’s Mr. Coleman,” Moore said. “He’s the only person that didn’t let it go. Making bad decisions is how crimes are committed.”

Testimony and evidence from traffic cameras showed the defendant and a friend ended up at the Gold Nugget that night while celebrating Coleman’s birthday. The victims and other friends also were celebrating a birthday and ended up at the Gold Nugget.

All were leaving at closing time when a comment about wanting to see a nice car do a “burnout” turned into an argument between the defendant and the victims. The victims said the defendant lifted his shirt at one point to show he had a pistol stuck in his waistband, so they decided to leave.

Video surveillance showed the defendant leaving in a vehicle driven by a friend, followed by the victims. The defendant’s friend testified he drove the defendant away to prevent any more arguing, circled the block to make sure the victims were not following him, then dropped his friend back off at his car at the Gold Nugget.

Traffic cameras showed Coleman then headed west, as the victims had, but was not headed home. His friend was behind him, concerned that Coleman was going after the younger group. The friend following Coleman was on the phone with him, pleading with him to go home and leave the first group alone.

Instead, Coleman continued to drive faster and told his friend, who was following further behind, “I’m going to follow them home and I’m going to beat these kids’ ass,” the friend testified. The friend testified that at some point in the phone conversation Coleman changed from saying he was going to beat them to he was going to shoot them.

“He was basically like saying he was going to follow them home and beat them up, over and over,” the friend testified. “And I was just like, hey, don’t do that, we should go home. Bad idea. There’s nothing good going to come out of this.

“Toward the end of the conversation he said he was going to shoot them and I heard gunshots rattle off over the phone.”

The victims, from the Greenwood area, had no idea they were being followed and were trying to find a hotel room when they pulled up to Back Beach Road on Allison Avenue and hit the red light. There, the defendant’s car pulled beside them and opened fire without warning.

The driver was struck in the hip; other bullets hit the driver’s and passenger’s doors before the defendant fled.

Coleman took the stand and testified on his own behalf, claiming the other group had flashed a gun at him at the club and he was only following them so he could get their tag number. He claimed when he pulled up to them at the light on the beach they shot at him, but there was no evidence found of that.

Moore pointed out that if Coleman was truly scared he would not have chased the vehicle, he would have called the police. He also noted that Coleman could have gotten their tag number at any point along Front Beach Road or Allison Avenue or even taken a picture of it.

“He wasn’t done after everyone left the parking lot,” Moore said. “If he was done and he was worried about his safety, he would’ve called the police. They were shot because he was so mad at them over the words that were exchanged and he wasn’t going to let it go.”

Coleman was tracked to his home the next morning.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.