Caulk Guilty of 2023 Homeless Camp Murder

Bay County Chief Prosecutor Mark Graham
Bay County Chief Prosecutor Mark Graham cross-examines the defendant

 

Charles Ed Caulk Wednesday was found guilty of Second-Degree Murder with a Firearm in the 2023 shooting death of a man at a homeless camp, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Circuit Court Judge Shonna Young Gay set sentencing for Jan. 8 at 8:30 a.m. The defendant faces a minimum of 25 years in prison and up to life.

Bay County Chief Prosecutor Mark Graham presented evidence and called witnesses – including several who saw the shooting – to prove Caulk fired a shot into the chest of Timothy “Nick” Kilgore without provocation the evening of Jan. 6, 2023. The 6-person jury reached its verdict in 1 hour and 45 minutes. Prosecutor Zach VanDyke assisted.

Caulk took the stand to claim he fired in self-defense – he said he feared for his life because the victim was approaching him during an argument, was known to carry a knife, refused orders to stop, and “he invaded my personal space, so I shot him.”

SAO Investigator Tyler Hill displays the murder weapon during questioning from Bay County Chief Prosecutor Mark Graham.

“The defendant violated our most scared law, he took a life,” Graham told jurors. “He took Nick Kilgore’s life that night for invading his personal

space. To be justified in using lethal or deadly force you need a clear danger or more than just ‘he invaded my personal space.’

Three witnesses to the shooting contradicted Caulk’s, saying the victim made no move toward him, was not holding a weapon or trying to get one, and was not posing any threat to anyone when the defendant pulled his pistol and shot him. The two men previously had a dispute involving a woman.

The defendant was at the homeless camp to retrieve some belongings when the victim, who had stayed there off and on, arrived.

Graham noted that all of the witnesses, including the defendant, said Caulk drew his gun, pulled the trigger but the gun did not fire, racked a round into the chamber, realized the safety was on and moved it to the “fire” position, and then pulled the trigger again before the gun fired.

“That’s a lot of premeditation,” Graham said.

The defendant also claimed that as the victim approached, he warned him. “I said I was going to act in self-defense mode if he didn’t back up,” the defendant testified.

“You don’t leave your common sense at the door when you’re on a jury,” Graham said to jurors in his closing argument. “Who in their right mind, in a situation like that, talks like that? It would be more colorful language that I’m not going to use here, but more like “Back your butt up or I’m about to put a hole in you.’ You don’t say, “Back up or I’m going to go into self-defense mode.”

As the defendant fled on foot, the witnesses performed CPR on the victim and called 911. On that recorded call, played for jurors, a witness described what had just happened.

RELATED: Donald Hawkins sentenced to 25 for child sex abuse

RELATED: 8 Life sentences in Calhoun child sex case

The caller told the 911 operator that the victim was shot at close range with a pistol and had no pulse.

“Where, where is the person with the gun?” the 911 operator asked.

“Ah, ah, his name is CJ, ah .. .”

“Where did he go?”

“He, he, just walked up to him and shot him, no reason, or no, no altercation, no nothin’ at all … he just walked up to him and pulled the trigger.”

The defendant was tracked to a boarding house where he was staying. The gun was found in a closet there. The bullet that killed the victim came from that gun, according to a Florida Department of Law Enforcement analyst.

Basford thanked the Panama City Police Department for its investigation into the shooting.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.

Fountain Man Guilty of Trafficking in Meth

A Fountain man was found guilty Thursday of Trafficking in Methamphetamine after an investigation and an “alert” from a drug-detecting K-9 led to the discovery of 58 grams of the drug he dumped in the vehicle, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.

Armando Cavazos, 44, is being held without bond pending his sentencing, which Circuit Court Judge Dustin Stephenson set for Oct. 6. Trafficking in Methamphetamine (more than 28 grams but less than 200 grams) is a First-Degree Felony punishable by a minimum-mandatory 7 years in prison and a maximum sentence of 30 years.

“These dealers keep bringing these deadly drugs into our community, and we will continue to take them to trial as our law enforcement partners continue to put them in jail,” Prosecutor Christopher Walters said. “The Bay County Sheriff’s Office Special Investigations Division and Sgt. Jeremy Head did another good job of getting to this defendant before he got his drugs onto our streets.”

Walters and Prosecutor Ben Bollinger called 5 witnesses – including two co-defendants who were in the vehicle when it was stopped – proving the methamphetamine found in the truck belonged to the defendant.

According to testimony, a co-defendant said he was going to install a radio in the defendant’s vehicle in exchange for some meth. While at the defendant’s property, he had to run home for some electrical tape and gave the defendant and another man a ride so they could stop at a nearby store.

They were under surveillance by members of the Bay County Sheriff’s Office SID. When the driver failed to stop at a stop sign, they were pulled over. Inv. Dwight Cummings deployed his K-9 for a “free-air” sniff around the car and it alerted to the presence of drugs.

Attorneys confer with Judge Dustin Stephenson

Investigators testified a baggie containing a white substance was visible on the back floorboard. When the car was searched investigators found the baggie contained 58 grams of what turned out to be methamphetamine.

RELATED: 20 Years for man who fled police while on probation for vehicular homicide

RELATED: One Stepp closer to prison after meth trafficking conviction

The driver of the vehicle testified that when deputies turned on their emergency lights to pull them over, he watched Cavazos, in the passenger’s seat, pull out a baggie filled with white powder and stuff it behind him onto the back floorboard.

The defendant was also found guilty of Tampering with a Witness. After his arrest, a recorded jail call showed he was trying to conspire with one of the co-defendants to blame the driver.

Basford thanked the Sheriff’s Office and SID for another investigation targeting a major dealer that concluded before the drugs could be sold on the street.

For more information, contact Mike Cazalas at mike.cazalas@sa14.fl.gov, or call 850-381-7454.