Our mission is to uphold the public’s trust in the pursuit of justice and the enforcement of the law. The Office of the State Attorney works to protect the public from those who endanger, threaten, and degrade the security of the community and to protect the personal rights of those we serve...more
State Attorney Larry Basford, right, speaks to family members of the victim.Defendant Michael Hunt was sentenced to death.
The man who led the targeted attempt to kill a witness against him in a human trafficking case in an attack that left a teenager dead and three other people critically wounded was sentenced to death Friday, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.
Michael Harrison Hunt, 58, was found guilty of First-Degree Murder and three counts of Attempted First-Degree Murder on Sept. 13. The jury voted 10-2 for the Death Penalty. Friday, Circuit Court Judge Shonna Young Gay followed that recommendation and ordered Hunt incarcerated until the sentence can be carried out.
“Michael Hunt is very dangerous,” Basford said after the sentencing. “He was involved in the human trafficking of young women. The reason we are here today is because he attempted to kill one of the victims that was going to testify against him.
“In the process he ended up killing a totally different teenager who had nothing to do with the case, along with attempting to kill three other people in the home,” Basford continued. “We agree with the jury and the judge that in this case, the death penalty is appropriate.”
Hunt planned the break-in at a Cove home on April 4, 2019, where the victim in a human trafficking case who was going to testify against him was staying. The intended victim hid and escaped harm, but Alexandra “Lexie” Peck, 19, who resembled the victim, was shot to death. Her stepfather Danny Scoggins was shot in the throat but was able to crawl next door for help. He has endured more than 60 surgeries since. Two other people in the house were shot but survived.
A collaborative investigation led by the Panama City Police Department with the Bay County Sheriff’s Office and State Attorney’s Office led to a manhunt for the defendant. He was arrested the following day.
Prosecutors Mark Graham and Peter Overstreet tried the case against Hunt and the jury reached a verdict in about an hour.
During sentencing, Judge Gay found that five aggravating factors had been proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and that they carried great weight. Gay found the defendant previously had been convicted of a crime involving violence, the murder occurred while committing a burglary, the murder was committed to disrupt or hinder a lawful investigation, the murder was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel, and that the murder was committed in a cold, calculated and premeditated manner.
PORT ST. JOE – A father and son who teamed up to burglarize a houseboat but were caught when their own boat had mechanical difficulties have been sentenced to 10 years each in prison, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.
Andy Hysmith, 63, and Anthony T. Hysmith, 41, who both listed Wewahitchka addresses, each pled guilty to Felon in Possession of a Firearm, Wearing a Mask While Committing a Burglary of a Dwelling, Possession of Burglary Tools, and Destruction or Tampering with Evidence.
Andy HysmithAnthony Hysmith
Gulf County Circuit Court Judge Devin Collier sentenced both men to 10 years in prison Friday. The first three years are a minimum/mandatory under Florida’s enhanced laws involving Felon in Possession of a Firearm.
The arrests and investigation were conducted by the Gulf County Sheriff’s Office and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission.
Chief Gulf County Prosecutor Tracy Smith was prepared to prove that on Jan. 31, 2023, the defendants broke into a houseboat near Bryant’s Landing and stole a number of items.
“Burglary is a serious crime and can be traumatic for the people whose private homes are violated,” Smith said. “We will continue to treat cases like this seriously, whether it’s a stand-alone home, a mobile home, or, as in this case, a houseboat.”
The evidence would have shown the owners of the houseboat were out of town, but the vessel was equipped with surveillance equipment that alerted him there were people on his boat. They contacted a friend and sent him surveillance footage, and that friend contacted deputies.
A deputy went to Bryant’s landing and saw a boat approaching, but it left when it saw his vehicle. Other deputies and law enforcement officers joined the search. The vessel was again spotted on the Chipola River and fled until it encountered a mechanical issue.
Evidence showed Andy Hysmith was seen throwing a firearm into the water and that both he and his son were wearing the same clothes as the two men in the surveillance footage. They also had items from the houseboat that belonged to the victim, some of which they also threw overboard.
Basford thanked the investigating agencies for their coordinated work in apprehending the suspects and making the arrests.
PORT ST. JOE – A Gulf County man found guilty of sexually molesting a child under the age of 12 has been sentenced to Life in prison.
Joseph Weldon Davis, 48, of Wewahitchka, was sentenced Friday after being found guilty Nov. 30 of Lewd or Lascivious Molestation. Circuit Court Judge Devin Collier ordered the maximum sentence and designated the defendant as a Sexual Predator.
“This sentence sends a strong message that crimes against children will not be tolerated and will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law,” said Gulf County Chief Prosecutor Tracy Smith.
Smith called witnesses and presented evidence proving the defendant sexually molested a child during a 5-month period in 2020 and 2021. The investigation that led to the defendant’s arrest March 9, 2021, was conducted by the Gulf County Sheriff’s Office.
Smith called 10 witnesses to the stand, including the victim. Smith also successfully argued that jurors should hear the testimony of two other females who said they were victims of similar acts by the defendant when they were juveniles.
The six-person jury took about 90 minutes to find the defendant guilty of the Lewd and Lascivious Molestation charge. The verdict carried a minimum-mandatory 25-year sentence but the defendant received the maximum Life sentence.
Basford thanked the Gulf County Sheriff’s Office and the Gulf Coast Children’s Advocacy Center for their work on the case and helping gathering the evidence needed for a conviction.
A drug dealer who sold what turned out to be a fatal dose of drugs to a 17-year-old was sentenced to 15 years in prison today after pleading guilty to Manslaughter, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.
Patrick Kelley Jones, 28, was given the maximum sentence by Circuit Judge Timothy Register for selling fentanyl-laced pills to a juvenile who died in 2021 after taking what he thought was the pain killer Roxicodone.
Prosecutor Peter Overstreet was prepared to call witnesses and produce evidence gathered by the Bay County Sheriff’s Office proving that Jones sold the pills that ended up killing the juvenile and tried to cover his tracks after he learned of the death.
The evidence would have shown that on July 24, 2021, the victim was found dead in his bedroom with a plastic baggie containing pills – stamped “M” on one side and “30” on the other – on a nearby table. The markings indicated the pills were Roxicodone, but test results showed they contained fentanyl. Subsequent tests showed the cause of death as Fentanyl Toxicity.
“This case is a tragic example of the dangers of selling drugs in our community,” Overstreet said. “A young man lost his life due to the fentanyl epidemic that is infecting our community. We will continue to punish those who deal drugs in our community to the fullest extent of the law.”
These pills sold as Roxicontin instead contained fentanyl.
Information and witnesses gathered by the Sheriff’s Office showed the victim bought the pills from the defendant the day before his death. When the defendant found out about the overdose, the evidence showed he changed his residence and phone number but continued to sell the pills.
Basford thanked the Bay County Sheriff’s Office for its work in building a strong case that led to a guilty plea.
BONIFAY – A man found guilty of attempting to lure what he thought was a 15-year-old girl into sexual acts through social media was sentenced to 15 years in prison Thursday, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.
John Edward McGlaun, 61, of Westville, will face 15 years of Sexual Offender probation after Prosecutor Ben Keown successfully argued he should be sentenced as a Habitual Felony Offender. Circuit Court Judge Russell Roberts, who presided over the Sept. 28 trial, handed down the sentence.
“The defendant tried to conceal his true intentions, but the facts of the case showed that his real motive was to prey on what he believed to be a 15-year-old girl,” Keown said. “The Holmes County Sheriff’s Office was proactive in its work on this case. They do these types of investigations to protect the community and ensure people like this never get to a child victim. We will continue to prosecute them thoroughly and use the enhanced sentencing tools that are available.”
John McGlaunPark where defendant was arrested.Message from defendant to what he thought was a 15-year-old teen.
The defendant was arrested in June, 2022, and went to trial on Sept. 28. After Keown presented his case, a jury took only about 15 minutes to find the defendant guilty of Traveling to Meet a Minor to Commit an Unlawful Sexual Conduct.
Keown called two witnesses: Holmes County Sheriff’s Office Lt. Bill Pate and Lt. Ricky Thompson.
Their testimony and evidence showed the defendant was in contact with who he believed to be a 15-year-old girl via Facebook Messenger and was attempting to talk her into meeting him for a sexual encounter. In fact, he was messaging with Inv. Pate, who was posing as a juvenile.
Through a series of messages the defendant arranged to meet the person for sex on June 21, 2022, at a Holmes County Park. McGlaun was arrested by deputies when he arrived at the park for the agreed-upon meeting.
Basford thanked the Holmes County Sheriff’s Office for its proactive work on the case and getting a sexual offender off the streets before he could victimize a child.
Top Left: Bryn Spivey, who set up the robbery. Top Right: Daquan Walker talks to his attorney. Bottom Right: Prosecutor Peter Overstreet speaks to the victim’s family. Bottom Left: Defendants Devarrious Winbush (head in hands) and Garen Dickens.
MARIANNA – Four men received prison terms ranging from 25 years to 50 years Thursday for their roles in a plan that ended with the death of a woman they were trying to rob on Oct. 1, 2020, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.
Brynn Spivey, 34, Daquan Walker, 28, and Garen Dickens, 40, all pled guilty to Second Degree Murder with a Firearm and Robbery with a Firearm. A fourth defendant, Devarroius Winbush, 29, pled guilty to Accessory After the Fact to Murder.
Circuit Court Judge Anna Maria Garcia sentenced Spivey, who initiated the plan and set up the robbery, to 50 years in prison. Dickens, one of two men who carried out the robbery during which the victim was shot, was sentenced to 45 years in prison. Walker, who was with Dickens and beside the victim during the shooting and who grabbed a bag from the victim after she was shot, was sentenced to 40 years in prison. Winbush, who was driving for Dickens and Walker, was sentenced to 25 years in prison. All four defendants ultimately cooperated to varying extents, something Judge Garcia considered.
Walker and Dickens gave essentially the same story as to what happened that day, except each claimed the other was the person who discharged a shotgun into the victim. Dannyelle Mari White, 33, was shot as she sat in the passenger’s seat of a truck and died instantly.
“At the end of the day, two individuals exited that vehicle knowing they were going to commit a robbery and Ms. White was tragically shot,” Overstreet said. “The issue becomes who pulled the trigger? What everyone agrees on is each played a role in Ms. White’s death.”
Judge Garcia, after sentencing Winbush, addressed Walker and Dickens.
“The only people here who know who actually shot the victim are (Walker and Dickens),” Garcia said. “I believe you both to be equally culpable and you both knew you were going to rob the victim.
“That will be reflected in your sentencing.”
Overstreet said dealing with all four defendants at one hearing means the family won’t have to repeat its testimony and relive the ordeal.
All four defendants addressed the court and the victim’s family during sentencing.
“Justice was served today for Ms. White’s murder,” he said. “The family, after waiting years for closure, can finally begin to heal. I want to thank the Jackson County Sheriff’s Office for their amazing work and investigation that led to all of the parties being held responsible.”
The victim’s stepmother also spoke in court. “Having her ripped away from our family is something from which we will never recover,” she said.
“She does not get to come home, this will never be over for us,” she continued. “We, her family, will have to learn to live without her. It has been three long years and we still have not learned how to do that.”
Prior to issuing the sentences, Garcia heard from each defendant and asked them to explain their role in the robbery and homicide, and how it unfolded, since she would be deciding the final punishment for everyone but Spivey, who had agreed to a 50-year sentence.
Prosecutor Peter Overstreet was prepared to provide witnesses and evidence, some of which was heard at Thursday’s sentencing, that Spivey was staying at a motel with his girlfriend and driving a truck his mother had rented. Spivey had given the victim a ride to a residence, where she had purchased about 20 grams of methamphetamine.
While that was happening, and on the ride back to the hotel, Spivey contacted Walker to tell him the victim was buying drugs and that he wanted Walker to get some help and rob her of those drugs when they returned to his hotel. Winbush was driving Walker, but did not know about the planned robbery, when they picked up Dickens and headed to the hotel.
Testimony during sentencing from the defendants showed that Spivey met the other three outside, gave them a key to the truck in case it was locked, told them where it was parked on the other side of the hotel, and that the victim was sitting in the passenger’s seat with the drugs.
Winbush thought he was driving the others to do a drug deal and they went around the hotel. Walker and Dickens saw the victim in the truck and approached it.
Walker said he opened the passenger’s door and Dickens demanded the victim, “give me everything you got.” When the victim refused and put a foot outside the truck, Walker said, Dickens shot her once and told him to grab the bag on the floorboard by her feet.
Dickins testified to the same sequence of events, except in reverse, saying he opened the door to the vehicle and it was Walker who demanded the drugs and then shot.
The shotgun was never recovered, and the bag the defendants grabbed did not have drugs in it.
Jackson County Sheriff’s Office investigators began a series of interviews that began by tracing the truck back to Spivey, confirming he had rented the hotel room, and then getting a warrant to search it since no one would answer the door. They found Spivey hiding inside.
His statements led them to Walker, and as the investigation continued with the State Attorney’s Office participation, all four defendants implicated themselves and each other.
Basford thanked the Jackson County Sheriff’s Office for the long hours and numerous interviews its investigators conducted that led to tracking down the four defendants, and for gathering strong evidence that helped lead to all four entering pleas.
TOP LEFT: Prosecutor Frank Sullivan elicits testimony from Bay County Sheriff’s Office Sgt. Jared Turner. BOTTOM LEFT: Sullivan during his closing argument to jurors. BOTTOM MIDDLE: Former BCSO Inv. Matthew Kutcher testifies. BOTTOM RIGHT: A bullet recovered from the scene is shown to jurors. RIGHT MIDDLE: The defendant and his attorney. TOP RIGHT: The defendant, in suit, addresses the court during his sentencing.
A 6-person jury took about 20 minutes Tuesday to find Jermel Cromartie guilty as charged of Attempted First Degree Murder for firing 12 shots at a man in 2019, striking him 8 times and putting him into a coma, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.
Jermel Cromartie, 33, was also found guilty of Tampering with a Victim for later contacting the man he shot and attempting to bribe him to change his story about who shot him. The intercepted call was played for jurors.
Prosecutor Frank Sullivan told the court that the act was particularly violent and the defendant remained a threat to the community. He requested enhanced penalties under Florida’s 10-20-Life law – two consecutive Life sentences. Circuit Court Judge Brantley Clark agreed.
Sullivan called witnesses and presented evidence gathered in the Bay County Sheriff’s Office investigation into the June 15, 2019, shooting. It proved the defendant shot at the victim 12 times – hitting him 8 to 9 times – while the two were a short distance away from the defendant’s Byrd Drive home in Callaway. The defendant ran home while the victim managed to crawl through a ditch and up beside the road, where passersby found him bleeding and crying for help.
Prosecutor Frank Sullivan shows jurors evidence that the victim was staying at the defendant’s residence.
“Angel Santos, with 9 holes in him as he crawled inch-by-inch through the sand and the ditch, was waiting for anybody to save his life,” Sullivan told jurors. “He thought it was over for him. If not for the people who stopped and got help, Angel Santos would be dead today.”
Motorists stopped to help, called 911 and comforted him. They said he was sure he was dying, and told them who shot him. He fell into a coma and had multiple surgeries before being able to give a statement to Bay County Sheriff’s Office investigators on July 31, again naming his attacker.
Sullivan told jurors that the victim’s survival was not Cromartie’s plan.
“The simple fact is Cromartie failed. By the grace of God and despite being shot so many times in so many parts of his body, Angel Santos survived,” Sullivan told jurors. “The defendant pulled that trigger 12 separate times. He intended to kill him and left him to die, laying like a dog in that field, and went about his way.”
In early 2020, the defendant contacted the victim via a three-way call from the jail and discussed how much he would pay the victim to contact the State Attorney’s Office and drop the charge. Instead, investigators discovered the call and contacted the victim, who confirmed the defendant was trying to pay him off.
Basford thanked the Sheriff’s Office for its work on the case, and the citizens who stopped and saved the victim, and then testified.
BLOUNTSTOWN – An Altha man was sentenced to 80 years in prison Wednesday after being found guilty as charged of 15 counts of Possession of Child Pornography, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.
A jury took less than an hour of deliberation to return its verdict against Benjamin Scott Donaldson, 42, following a two-day trial. Circuit Court Judge Brandon Young then sentenced the defendant to 15 years in prison on Count 1, and 5 years each on the remaining 14 counts to be served consecutively, for a total of 80 years.
Benjamin Donaldson
Judge Young also designated the defendant as a Sexual Offender.
Chief Calhoun County Prosecutor William Wright successfully argued that the court should allow testimony from a woman who was a young teen when Donaldson victimized her in a 2014 case. She was one of 5 witnesses called by the state.
The investigation began in 2021 when the Florida Department of Law Enforcement received a tip from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC). After a thorough investigation by the FDLE with assistance from the Calhoun County Sheriff’s Office, evidence showed the defendant used his cell phone at work and at home to download illegal images of child pornography, including images of young girls being sexually battered.
The trial began Monday with jury selection, and concluded Wednesday.
Basford thanked Wright and the staff at the SAO’s Blountstown office, along with the FDLE and CCSO for their diligent work on the case.
Defendant Charles Peterson, center. Top left: FDLE tools show a bullet’s trajectory. Top right: The victim’s car. Bottom left: The defendant’s shoe which was tied to footprints at the scene. Bottom right: FDLE taking plaster casts of shoe impressions at the scene.
MARIANNA – A 38-year-old man who entered an open plea to Second-Degree Murder is in prison today as he begins a 40-year-sentence for shooting and killing a man in his car two years ago.
Charles Edward Peterson, of Marianna, was sentenced to 40 years in prison Nov. 17 after entering an open plea in the Dec. 31, 2021, homicide of Quinton Jerome Beckwith, 33, also of Marianna. Circuit Court Judge Ana Maria Garcia sentenced the defendant under Florida’s 10-20-Life enhanced penalty statute. The first 25 years are minimum/mandatory.
The Jackson County Sheriff’s Office investigated the shooting, interviewed witnesses and developed Peterson as a suspect. As part of a collaborative effort, Champaign, Ill., police, at the request of Jackson County authorities, detained the defendant when he got off a bus there.
Chief Jackson County Prosecutor Shalla Jefcoat was prepared to present witnesses and evidence at trial proving the defendant fired three shots from a semi-automatic pistol through a rear passenger window of the victim’s car. The victim, sitting in the driver’s seat of the car parked outside a relative’s home, was able to exit the vehicle but collapsed near the front door of the relative’s home.
Jefcoat was prepared to prove to jurors that the defendant was upset about a fight he had with the victim about a week before the shooting. He told witnesses he was going to kill the victim. Just prior to the shooting witnesses said he was going to the victim’s location with a tan Glock 19x.
A Glock 19x like that used in the homicide.
A short time later, other witnesses heard several gunshots from inside the nearby home. The defendant had approached the victim’s vehicle from behind and to the right before firing three shots through a back rear window at the victim. Shell casings there were matched ballistically to a gun the defendant had stolen from a friend and then dumped in the woods after the shooting. A pair of shoes belonging to the defendant, which were found near the gun, were matched to shoe impressions taken from the scene of the shooting.
Basford thanked the JCSO for its work in developing a suspect and tracking him to Illinois, and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement for its ballistics and shoeprint experts.
A man found guilty by a jury Oct. 31 of shooting a clerk during an attempted robbery was sentenced to Life in prison Monday under Florida’s 10-20-Life law, State Attorney Larry Basford announced.
Prosecutor Peter Overstreet at trial.
Kedrick Jamal McNeil, 27, was convicted two weeks ago of Attempted Robbery with Discharge of a Firearm causing Great Bodily Harm, Aggravated Battery with a Firearm causing Great Bodily Harm, and Felon in Possession of a handgun.
Prosecutor Peter Overstreet successfully argued that the defendant should be sentenced under Florida’s 10-20-Life law. He also showed the defendant was a Habitual Violent Felony Offender and a Prison Release Reoffender.
“He had been out of prison less than a year and our office will continue to take a tough stance on the use of firearms in a crime, particularly by a previously convicted felon who has been to prison,” Overstreet said.
Circuit Court Judge Timothy Register sentenced the defendant to Life on each of the first two charges under Florida’s enhanced penalties for those who use firearms during the commission of certain crimes.
Overstreet called seven witnesses at trial, including the victim who was shot in the thigh during the attempted robbery. He also presented evidence gathered by Bay County Sheriff’s Office investigators to prove the defendant attempted to rob the Beeline Convenience store in Callaway on Sept. 9, 2021, and shot the clerk when she refused to give him money.
A Bay County jury took less than an hour to return a guilty verdict.
